Rising Star Jake Thistle writes ‘em, sings ‘em and plays ‘em with an air of nonchalant cool. Part of it is genes. He was born that way. Yet he’s cultivated an image of devil-may-care insouciance that adds immeasurably to his over-all oeuvre. I don’t even think he does it on purpose…like how Elvis wasn’t even aware at first that he was shaking his leg when he sang. He comes off like the boy-next-door, with that captivating smile, and that aw-shucks demeanor. Ask him about his experience on American Idol earlier this year where—out of thousands of contestants—he made it into The Top 14. “I had no idea what to expect,” he admits, “but realized very early on in the process how much of a privilege it would be to go through the experience with such a talented group of writers and performers who were also auditioning. The sense of community between the contestants, producers, and judges was an environment that taught me a lot and I’ll remember it for a long time.”
This is one serious singer-songwriter whose casual approach belies the deep gravity within his grooves. Lyric-wise, he’s articulate. Sorta like a new improved Jackson Browne. Talking to him is, in a word, refreshing. Listening to his new album, A Stranger By Design, is to discover a new New Jersey Voice.
“I legitimately believe that New Jersey is the greatest place on the planet, without exaggeration,” he says. “I’m more than happy to be marketed as a Jersey guy. That said, there’s a specific aura, especially visually, when it comes to New York, and the skyline.”
Jake Thistle on American Idol
Trying to fathom his lyrical meanings is a fool’s game. “I don’t always feel like I have something particular to say,” he admits, “so it makes the time in-between writing these songs somewhat uncomfortable, where I’m not sure exactly what ‘vibe’ to lean into for the project as a whole. Because of that, I was motivated to create A Stranger By Design because of my pride in the stories I’ve chosen to tell in this collection of music. When I feel like I’ve written (what I consider) to be a ‘good song,’ I try very hard to not take that feeling for granted, and to hold onto it during a time where the writing doesn’t come as easy. Since we’ve recorded this project over the course of over two years, I feel like the album acts as exactly that; a record of where I was, both physically and mentally, during a very formative part of my life, where during the process I also left my teenage years, graduated college, toured in 10 countries, and was on American Idol. The point is, I ‘created’ this record because it’s what I love to do - but I’m motivated to release this record to share where I’ve been the last few years, as well as show that I’m ready to close that chapter and take a new look at everything for the next project.”
Sounds of the State: Jake and Bruce
In other words, this cat ain’t standing still. It’s called being a true artist, and, as we all know, true artists always change. That doesn’t mean one shouldn’t dig a little deeper to hear Jake’s previous work. But Jake says, “this feels like my most faithful musical introduction yet. I’m very proud of my other two releases, but I think these songs are the most ‘accurate’ to the way I’ve wanted my sound to represent the cross-section of my influences. They move me overall into a place I’d like to continue exploring. While I, of course, would like to have a ‘hit song’ off the bat and end up touring large venues, etc., I’m honestly most interested in establishing myself as a songwriting voice that has some stability, consistency, and longevity, so I hope this record ends up cultivating some of those thoughts. I’d take long-term moderate appeal over short-term reverence (although I suppose I’d take either).” He laughs. Then he says, “so, I hope fans take away from this release a sense of investment in the project as they want to hear my sound evolve.”
Thoughtful dude. But is there a specific emotion he wants people to feel while listening to this new album? The answer comes quick. “Not particularly,” he says, “It’s important to me that fans take what they choose to out of the musical and lyrical content. On the surface, a lot of the songs are about some form of longing, nostalgia, or solitude, so as a writer I hope those things come across, but most importantly, I just want the audience to feel something that keeps them coming back to both these specific songs and my writing as a whole. However, it’s only an individual and their own experiences and worldview that will determine how they specifically interpret a song, and I’m more than okay with that.”
That said, we asked Jake to personally write a short synopsis of each new song.
Alley Minded
Written in a Nashville hotel where there was another building so close to my window that I couldn’t see out or have light come in, I wanted to explore that as a metaphor for closing yourself off and reflecting on the lonely consequences that follow.
Alone, Together
Mostly written about the NJ turnpike, where two worlds, the beauty of the Manhattan skyline, and the abrasiveness of the power conversion plants and landfills of New Jersey can be seen together. Two industrial giants, yet so different in such close proximity.
Better That Way
One of the more straightforward tracks on the record, it’s about deciding to be comfortable in your situation (whether you should be or not), because you may as well be okay with something if you have to do it anyway. The core of “Better That Way” is a character who would rather fight and lose, than run from a fight and have to live with his own pusillanimity.
Blankest Page
Last summer I was talking about songwriting with Jackson Browne, and he told me a story about Paul Simon, saying something along the lines of, “Paul said to me, everywhere I go I’m writing by observing. I’m writing a song in the grocery store, picking up the kids from school, everywhere. Sitting in front of a page is just getting those experiences out.” That story stuck with me, so I ended up trying to display that concept in a song. The core in “Blankest Page” is a character who is thinking of a past partner in everyday life, but is hesitant to put it into words for a song because they don’t want their partner to know how much they’re thinking about them. The page essentially taunts the character, its emptiness calling for them to write on it.
Carpool Lane
Like a few other tracks on this record, the “Carpool Lane” is obviously a metaphor for wishing you weren’t alone. Driving out of a city, reflecting on a life the character is leaving, they also wish instead of fleeing their past, they were actually with an old love going to a place of comfort.
The City Whispers
This song is a character looking for a moment of quiet in a busy city. I’ve always viewed the main character here as a bit of an unreliable narrator, though, where they’re using the ‘hustle and bustle’ of city life as an excuse to not reflect on their depression, shortcomings, or unresolved feelings.
Hiding In the Vacancy
At its most simple this song is about not being able to sleep. There’s a character who is trying to retire for the night, but is stuck awake thinking about old mistakes, lovers, and fighting their own inner dialogue about where their life is heading.
Idling Car
This song is mostly about the realization that you don’t get replaced by an older version of yourself who magically knows how to be an adult, but instead need to learn and grow into being the person you already are. This character is on an aimless/directionless journey running from that feeling, despite the fact that they know the score deep down.
The Only Man To Make It Through The Dance
Probably the most ambiguous meaning on the record, “The Only Man” is mostly about feeling like you’re the only one struggling and reflecting on the fact that you feel alone.
Silver Bullet Sky
The first song I wrote for this record. Written in my junior year apartment at Rutgers, there was a window that looked out into a courtyard with a bike rack. Someone had left a bike locked up there for months, and I’d watch it every day, in all weather and conditions completely still, as the tires gently hemorrhaged air and the frame slowly rusted. That image became the center of a song mostly about juxtaposing the freedom and finality of forces of nature.
Sleep On Me
One side of a late night conversation, “Sleep On Me” is about someone asking for a second chance. Essentially it’s “think on this, don’t leave right now. I’ll make it up to you, you’ll see.” I’ve always been skeptical that the narrator actually improves on themself, though it’s not discussed in the song.
Sweeter Than The Same
This song is a story about someone going alone to a familiar spot, where they’d formerly gone with a lover, to reminisce and reflect about the relationship. The location makes the main character feel closer to this other person, and the frequency of which they go makes them a familiar face.
Wearing Out The Neighborhood
Probably the most autobiographical song on the record by far, I frequently have trouble sleeping and go on late night walks, especially when I was at school and living in more of a city. One night, I wrote this song about going on one of those walks INSTEAD of going on that walk. It’s a character who can’t sleep, so he decides he needs to take a break from trying, so he takes a walk through his neighborhood during a soft rain, and reflects on the streetlights, billboards, weather, and his own thoughts.”